On
January 29,2002, the Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA)
sponsored a 1-day Information Industry Summit in New York City. Some 200
executives from all types of firms in the information industry attended
the program designed to help them in "Meeting the New Challenges."
In his keynote
address at the Summit, Michael Wilens, president of West Group, made observations
about how the Internet revolution changed information technology and what
could be learned from the economic downturn in the information industry
last year. In a panel discussion that followed, entitled "Rethinking the
Information Company, Gaining from Adversity," Lisa Mitnick, senior vice
president, Legal and Tax Solutions, from LexisNexis, also noted that the
rise and fall of many Web companies has created opportunities for established
companies to acquire innovative businesses, technology, and talent that
she believes will revitalize the traditional information industry. As a
follow-up, both Wilens and Mitnick were interviewed about how West Group
and LexisNexis, both leaders in legal and business information, are responding
to these challenges and opportunities.
Web Migration
Wilens used several
visual analogies in his keynote address to explain why information companies
were hurt financially when users migrated from other media to the Web.
He compared the early adopters of technology to the leading edge of a slinky
and the bulk of users to the trailing edge, which holds off until the last
minute and then jumps all at once. A double bubble economic model occurs,
he explained, when risk-averse customers, the trailing edge of the slinky,
buy the same product twice in different media and create a revenue bump.
But when the majority of users finally accepts a new technology, as they
did last year, the slinky effect occurs, the second bubble bursts, and
revenue declines. Wilens and Mitnick were both asked about the effect that
migration of users to the Web had on their companies and on future business
strategies.
Rapid Change
The Internet also
eliminated the advantage of proprietary platforms and energized product
development, according to Wilens, which created both challenges and opportunities
for the industry. In his keynote, he stated that product cycles have decreased
from 3 years to as little as weeks because of new Web technology. The upside
of these shorter time frames is the ability to quickly respond to competitive
demands, but it can also lead to an unstable product with more changes
than customers may want.
Wilens pointed
out the difficulty in predicting whether advances in content, technology,
or distribution will drive the future direction of the industry. He compared
it to the three-body problem in physics which holds that when three or
more objects interact with each other, their trajectory is impossible to
calculate. What is critical, Wilens explained, is to be able to respond
rapidly to change when it occurs. As a follow-up, Wilens and Mitnick were
asked how the advances in information technology brought about by the Internet
revolution have affected their products and how they are preparing for
new developments that might occur in content, technology, or distribution.
Merging Old and New
In her talk, Mitnick
pointed out that the traditional information companies that came through
last year financially intact now stand to benefit from the post-dot-com
shakeout. The current buyers' market offers opportunities to reinvigorate
products and services,she noted,through investments in acquisitions, new
talent, and infrastructure. More over, the integration of innovative Web
services with the depth and breadth of traditional services should produce
a new generation of products and services that will transcend what has
gone before. Both Wilens and Mitnick were asked to describe how their companies
have benefited or expect to benefit from the Web revolution in this respect.
Interview with
Michael Wilens
How was West
affected by the migration of users to the Web?
West's print business
remained flat and relatively unaffected by the Web last year because lawyers
still love the leather books. The CD-ROM business was a different story
and had a much higher attrition rate, as subscribers dropped subscriptions
and began to rely solely on the Web for electronic access. The online growth
last year was 11 percent and currently represents 60 percent of the business.
The positive effect of this change is that actual usage has increased 40
percent and support costs are lower than for CD-ROMS. The challenge for
the company, but good for the customer, is that the Web is much more competitive
than CD-ROM, since the competition is just a click away.
What effect
will these changes in usage have on your business strategy going forward?
West will introduce
West Pack to drive business from both the print and online sides of its
business. West Pack combines access to online databases with print subsets
at a discounted rate. The cannibalistic effect has been accounted for in
this year's plan and a recent pilot demonstrated exceptional market acceptance.
How have
the advances in information technology brought about by the Web revolution
affected West's products and how are you utilizing the faster product development
cycles to get closer to your customers?
It is easier and
faster to change a Web site than a CD-ROM, and, with over 60 percent of
users now on the Web, West can upgrade its service and add features and
new content more readily. However, continuous upgrades annoy some customers
who prefer a more stable interface. West has responded by introducing My
Westlaw, which allows users to personalize their interface by selecting
just the new features they will use. For example, a medical malpractice
lawyer might need to change the interface in order to see JPGs of a new
collection of medical pictures, but a lawyer in a different practice area
could ignore the feature. Change is controlled within tabs pre-organized
by practice areas. Enhancements can be purchased as optional tabs, which
are easy to turn on. West has also leveraged advances in built-in, interactive
help and natural language to make the service easier for first-time users.
How is West
prepared to respond to the three-body problem, i.e., developments in content,
technology, or distribution, which may have a major impact on the market
and direction of the industry?
Last year, West
invested in infrastructure and acquisitions, and 2002 will be a year of
consolidation and deployment. Westlaw is moving to a new platform, a collection
of large Sun servers with very large memory footprints (internally named
Novus), and will migrate over 100 terabytes of data from its mainframes
to Novus in the next 2-3 years. Among other benefits, this will result
in fast XML content searching, as well as the ability to more easily develop
extensively customized products.
West has also positioned
itself to be technology neutral in the area of productivity tools. West
originally developed WestWorks, an integrated practice and information
management system, as an ASP and DSL solution. However, when it became
apparent that ASP and DSL telecommunications were problematic for some
firms, West purchased ProLaw, a leading provider of case management software,
and merged it with West Works. ProLaw is a client server package that runs
on a law firm's own server, and it has widgets that plug into many different
portal solutions. Thus, it doesn't require firms to change their infrastructure
or invest in new technology in order to deploy it. Over time, ProLaw will
provide its software on either a client-server or ASP basis.
West is also ready
for a wireless revolution. Users started with print, moved to proprietary
online service, then to CD-ROMS, and then to the Web. The Web leveled the
playing field and eliminated desktop footprint. Going forward, people are
becoming "always on," with wireless devices, beepers, instant messengers,
cell phones, and GPS receivers in their cars. West has built Westlaw Wireless,
a wireless product accessible through a variety of devices (e.g., Palm
Pilot), and makes it free to subscribers. In addition to allowing users
to access Westlaw content, directories, KeyCite, and e-mail from remote
locations, the wireless service turned out to have an unexpected outcome.
As an interesting unexpected bonus, the simplified interface for wireless
access has been redeployed to provide special tailored access for blind
researchers who need simple screens for their reader software.
How has West
benefited or does it expect to benefit from the dot-com shakeout? Can you
give examples of new alliances or acquisitions West has made that will
blend Web innovation with Westlaw's deep content?
During the height
of the dot-com boom, technologists were hard to hire. This year, West has
been able to recruit and hire top-notch people from former dot-com companies
with a mixture of traditional and Web experience. At the start of the downturn,
West also acquired FindLaw, a Web legal site with huge traffic, but minimal
revenue. This is a case of cultures working together. It gives West new
content, an expanded presence on the Web, and it provides FindLaw with
the resources to develop and expand its services. FindLaw also expands
the West Legal Directory service substantially, making it competitive with
the Martindale Hubbard Directory on LexisNexis.
What would
you most like to see West accomplish in 2002?
2002 will be a
three-legged stool: 1) West will focus on its premium content, add more
value-added, unreported cases, and strive to remain the highest-quality
provider; 2) West also plans to lead the market in innovation with services
such as knowledge management, ProLaw, and FindLaw; and 3) West will focus
on customer satisfaction by hiring a senior customer experience czar and
incorporating the best of e-commerce, online customer service solutions.
Interview with
Lisa Mitnick
How has LexisNexis
been affected by the .migration of users to the Web?
LexisNexis user
migration has gone from its proprietary software and services to an array
of Web-based information services introduced in the mid-'90s. The migration
of LexisNexis customers to the Web has opened the doorway to reach new
users across the enterprise, to deliver greater functionality and better
product offerings. In addition, the Web platform is more readily accessible,
and the training process is more streamlined and cost-effective.
What effect
will these changes in usage have on your business strategy going forward
now that the migration is largely completed on LexisNexis?
We will continue
to grow our business on the Web, leveraging its solid foundation to couple
comprehensive information with the best Web innovations and solutions.
How have
the advances in information technology brought about by the Web revolution
affected LexisNexis's products, and how are you utilizing the faster product
development cycles to get closer to your customers?
The Web is the
best thing that ever happened to the traditional information industry.
It has been a wake-up call to re-tool our approach and enhance our competitive
stance. The next generation of LexisNexis products will mirror customer
activity cycles and leverage Web technologies to produce functional, task-based
solutions along with enterprise-wide services. They also will capitalize
on our global technology infrastructure to allow products and services
to be customized for individual geographic areas and needs, while using
a common platform and consistent underlying navigation. This is increasingly
important to companies doing business on a global basis.
How is LexisNexis
prepared to respond to the three-body problem, i.e., developments in content,
technology, or distribution, which may have a major impact on the market
and direction of the industry?
LexisNexis is making
investments in and leveraging all three. We are integrating high-value
content with technology to deliver task-based applications that enhance
productivity and improve decision-making. LexisNexis has focused on acquiring
proprietary, value-added content, such as Shepard's and Matthew Bender,
and signed exclusive licensing agreements with CCH, Tax Analysts, and Congressional
Quarterly. At the same time, we have invested significantly in XML technology
to enhance the value of this content. LexisNexis has created a gateway
that converts content to XML on the fly and enables us to deliver the content
in the format customers want. LexisNexis SmartIndexing is also applied
across all news content. In addition, we frequently work closely with our
customers to deliver customized taxonomies and indexing that reside on
their intranets in the form of a customized user interface. LexisNexis
has a full suite of e-solutions which facilitate publishing of content
inside and outside an organization, as well as corporate portal solutions.
And we currently have a strategic alliance with Plumtree Software by which
we deliver a legal portal.
How has LexisNexis
benefited or does it expect to benefit from the dot-com shakeout? Can you
give examples of new alliances or acquisitions LexisNexis has made that
will blend Web innovation with LexisNexis's deep content?
LexisNexis came
out of 2001 with solid results, and it is well-positioned to take advantage
of opportunities that might arise. Throughout 2000 and 2001, LexisNexis
made a number of acquisitions, including Pressaccess, Riskwise International,
and Courtlink, all three of which are examples of acquisitions which will
be combined with other LexisNexis content to create task-based e-solutions.
Pressaccess is a dot-com business providing public-relations solutions
for PR executives to manage their calendars, find, and talk to journalists.
Riskwise is a comprehensive set of risk management solutions and provides
due diligence, consulting services, real-time identity verification, and
other value-added services. Courtlink provides Web-based services for electronically
filing legal documents and accessing and monitoring court records.
LexisNexis has
also been actively pursuing technology alliances. A good example is our
relationship with iPhrase. iPhrase's natural-language search and navigation
technology is being integrated with LexisNexis's Advertising Red Books
and Directory of Corporate Affiliations. The integrated applications will
allow users to type in natural-language queries and get back context-sensitive
questions, targeted results, and hierarchical representations such as corporate
trees from the data. Reed Elsevier's (LexisNexis's parent company) Venture
Group made an investment in iPhrase and is investing in other start-ups
with high potential and close synergies with LexisNexis's business strategy.
What would
you most like to see LexisNexis accomplish in 2002?
We will continue
to increase customer satisfaction and preference, partnering with our clients
to deliver world-class, easy-to-use information solutions. To that end,
we will continue to invest in content, technology, and distribution that
enable us to solidify and expand our customer base globally.
Keep Your
Eyes on These Two
West Group and
LexisNexis are both worth watching for all information professionals. Their
intense competition keeps them on the leading edge of development. As such,
their strategies are good indicators of the direction we can expect firms
in the professional information industry to take in the future. Rivals
since the introduction of Lexis in the 1970s, the companies have always
pushed each other to compete. If one gained an advantage through new content
or technology, the other would soon adopt or develop a similar feature
or product.
For many years,
however, West maintained a distinction with its origins as a law book publisher
and its proprietary topic, key number, and head note indexing. West's print
business also lent itself to CD-ROM products when the technology emerged
in the late 1980s. With its origins as an online service, LexisNexis did
not compete with West in that distribution channel or in print. It also
opened up the area of full-text service to news media. However, West is
now moving away from its CD-ROM business as its customers migrate to the
Web, and LexisNexis is not only developing taxonomies and indexing systems,
it has also acquired Matthew Bender, a publisher of case law and legal
analysis, and Shepard's Citations, which are available in print and CD-ROM
as well as online media. It appears that both companies recognize the importance
of high- value, proprietary books and information to their customers and
will leverage them to sell other services.
Both West and LexisNexis
are also adopting XML technology. This will allow them to customize products
and support the productivity and management tools under development. At
the moment, each has its own different legal portal strategies for delivering
those tools, with West providing ubiquitous software and LexisNexis partnering
with a market leader in enterprise portal solutions. However, both are
trying to own the law office desktop and could be expected to change directions
quickly as soon as a preferred solution emerges. It is also likely that
LexisNexis is monitoring the adoption of wireless technology by users pretty
closely. If Westlaw Wireless achieves a competitive advantage for West,
LexisNexis can be expected to respond with its own product.
Clearly both companies
have become more customer-centric, with customer needs driving product
development, use of natural language tools, and customization of content,
taxonomy, and even interfaces, with West offering interface customization
at the user level and LexisNexis developing it at the regional level worldwide.
Certainly, one
of the most hopeful and unexpected outcomes of the dot-com fallout is the
adoption and integration of innovative Web services and technologies into
the Westlaw and LexisNexis services. Both companies stand to benefit significantly
from the tremendous investment and advances made in information technology
during the boom years. Likewise, customers can expect to benefit from the
improvements both will bring to their products and services. By acquiring
and funding innovative dot-com companies, West and LexisNexis will also
preserve some of the best Web sites from the demise of many other sites
that offered valuable information and services to customers, but were unable
to generate sustaining revenues on the Web.
Clearly, West and
LexisNexis are successfully meeting the challenges to the industry and
their actions indicate leading trends we can expect to see this year in
increased customization; adoption of XML technology; portal solutions,
productivity, and knowledge management tools; print/online combinations;
improvements in customer service; and integration of Web technologies and
services with deep knowledge bases. |
|